Claude just started watermarking everything. Here's what that actually means.


Sir Steve-a-lot

Author, Writing Coach

Hey Reader,

Something happened this week that's worth talking about — especially if you've been following along with what I've been sharing about writing with AI.

As of August 2nd, Claude started embedding an invisible watermark into every piece of text it generates. You can't see it. It doesn't change how the writing reads. But it travels with the text when you copy and paste it, and AI detection tools will be able to find it.

A lot of people are panicking about this. I get it.

But here's what I actually think:

The watermark isn't your real problem. Letting AI do your thinking for you is.

If you hit a button, got a draft, changed a few words, and called it your book — that's the problem. Not because a detector might catch it, but because it's not yours. Your readers will feel that, watermark or no watermark.

But if you used Claude as a collaborator — to help you get your own ideas out of your head and onto the page — and then you went to town on that draft, rewrote it in your voice, cut what didn't sound like you, added your own stories and your own texture — that document is yours. The watermark might technically still be there, but it doesn't matter if you have nothing to hide.

That's the only version of AI-assisted writing I teach. And it's the only version I'd stake my reputation on.

Here's what I tell everyone I coach: treat the AI draft like a lump of clay. It gives you something to react to instead of a blank page. But you're the sculptor. If you hand someone a lump of clay and call it a finished piece, that's on you — not the clay.

Go to town on it.

Rewrite it.

Make it sound like you talked it out loud over coffee.

Cut the parts that sound like a LinkedIn post.

Add the thing you almost didn't include because you weren't sure it was relevant.

That's where your book actually lives.

The writers who are going to get kneecapped by watermarking and AI detection are the ones who were never really writing in the first place.

You're not one of those people. At least, I'm assuming you're not — otherwise you wouldn't still be reading this.

Steve

P.S. — OpenAI, Google, and Meta have all committed to the same EU transparency code. Switching tools won't get you out of this. The watermarking era is here for everyone. The only real answer is to write something that's actually yours.

Av. Costa Negra 323, Chorrillos, Lima 15067
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Fire On Your Head

I help authors get clear on what actually works in publishing — before they spend time or money going down the wrong road.

Read more from Fire On Your Head

Hey Reader, I have a confession. I've been coaching other people to finish their books for years while my own memoir sat on my hard drive doing nothing. The earliest material in it goes back to around 2015. Some of it older than that. Journal entries, blog posts, notes from seasons of ministry in Lima, documents I'd written for different purposes over different years that I always suspected had a book somewhere inside them. The problem was I couldn't see it. I could feel that there was...